Why Jay Schwedelson Says Attribution in Marketing is Garbage

Digital artwork with a black and white portrait and marketing elements.

Attribution in Email Marketing: Why It May Be Overrated

In the world of marketing, attribution often dictates how success is measured. Yet industry expert Jay Schwedelson, CEO of Outcome Media and founder of SubjectLine.com, boldly claims that this focus on attribution is misguided. According to Schwedelson, the true power of email marketing lies not in tracking clicks or conversions, but in the cumulative effect of sustained communication with your audience.

Rethinking the Inbox as a Social Space

Schwedelson encourages marketers to reframe how they view email. He suggests thinking of the inbox as a “social scroll” where the key is engaging your audience with valuable content rather than bombarding them with promotional offers. “If ‘cold email’ is your go-to-market, or you only send out promotional emails, you will fail miserably,” he warns. The most effective strategy is to nurture relationships through consistent, informative communication before making requests.

Holdout Groups: A Better Way to Measure Impact

While measuring efforts is important, Schwedelson introduces a unique approach called “holdout groups” to better gauge the true effectiveness of email campaigns. By isolating a small segment of your database—around 5-10%—from marketing efforts, you can draw clearer conclusions about the influence of your broader campaigns. “It’s a way to understand what you might be missing,” he explains, helping marketers to find the balance between measurable outcomes and the invisible threads that build brand awareness.

The Future of Marketing Is About Value, Not Attribution

As the marketing landscape evolves, so must our strategies. Schwedelson’s insights offer a refreshing perspective: the most crucial factor is how well brands communicate value to their audiences over time, rather than focusing predominantly on attribution metrics. Embracing this mindset could redefine how businesses approach their marketing efforts, paving the way for deeper connections that are ultimately more beneficial than mere numbers.

Emerging Trends

0 Comments

Write A Comment

Related Posts All Posts

12.10.2025

Why Community and Authenticity Matter in 2025's Marketing Landscape

Discover how 2025 marketing trends focus on community and authenticity, emphasizing AI's role in personalization and the need for deeper consumer connections.

12.09.2025

Discover 3 Innovative Growth Hacks to Thrive in an AI Marketing Era

Update Adapting in an AI-Dominated World: A New Playbook In the past five years, businesses have faced unprecedented transformation, accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic. The rise of generative AI has rewritten the rules of the market, challenging established brands to rethink their strategies in a landscape reminiscent of the internet boom of the 1990s. Companies that were once at the forefront of digital innovation now find themselves level with new entrants, all leveraging the power of AI to enhance their marketing capabilities. Harnessing AI for Competitive Advantage According to a recent HubSpot study involving 1,800 global brand professionals, successful growth teams are shifting towards strategies that embrace a continuous loop of learning and adaptation. This 'Loop Marketing' approach emphasizes the need for clear brand positioning—yet, shockingly, only 51% of marketers have a documented unique value proposition (UVP). This gap signifies a missed opportunity: brands without a well-defined positioning often struggle to meet their goals. Innovative Strategies for Today’s Marketers To thrive in this AI-saturated environment, companies must prioritize data-driven decision-making and hyper-personalized marketing tactics. AI enables businesses to analyze vast amounts of data to predict customer preferences and automate engagement, facilitating a level of personalization that traditional methods cannot match. Businesses that incorporate predictive analytics and AI-driven insights are witnessing significant boosts in campaign performance, often reporting returns on investment as high as 20% or more. Building Lasting Brand Relationships As consumer expectations evolve, so must brands’ strategies. Ignoring emerging trends like real-time adaptability and personal engagement can lead to missed connections with potential customers. By leveraging AI tools, marketers can foster ongoing relationships, addressing customer needs proactively—transforming the marketing approach from static to dynamic. The Future Landscape of Marketing Looking ahead, marketing strategies will not only evolve but adapt continuously—fueled by AI innovations that allow brands to react in real-time. The integration of machine learning, natural language processing, and advanced analytics will help brands craft messages that resonate deeply with consumers. The future is about harnessing intelligent tools that not only protect but also enhance brand integrity and relationship-building efforts. The evidence is clear: businesses that embrace these new methodologies and technologies are the ones that will thrive. Whether it's through automated social media engagement or personalized email marketing driven by AI insights, the key to growth lies in adapting to change and utilizing technology as an ally in creating effective and meaningful connections.

12.07.2025

Lessons on Leadership: Insights from a Traveling Circus Ringmaster

Update Understanding Circus Leadership: The Lessons from a Ringmaster After a deep dive into the world of a circus led by Kevin Venardos, the owner and ringmaster of the Venardos Circus, we find unique insights that offer profound lessons on leadership. His journey from struggling with debt to leading a thriving circus reflects timeless tenets of effective leadership applicable to any business. Lesson One: Dreams Can Inspire Collective Success Venardos began with a simple yet ambitious dream: to keep performing and creating joy for others, even amidst struggles. This approach evolved into a philosophy where helping others achieve their dreams became a central theme. When Venardos placed his circus adjacent to a local carnival, he discovered the local economic impact he could have. This realization is a reminder for leaders everywhere: when dreams align, it fosters a mutually beneficial environment. Collaboration with local businesses and communities can enhance overall success and create an ecosystem where everyone thrives. Lesson Two: The Importance of Emotional Investment In the context of ongoing challenges, Venardos’s narrative underlines the value of emotional connections. When the pandemic threatened their existence, the emotional bonds forged with audience members allowed Venardos Circus to pivot creatively. Selling tickets for a live-stream event, even when free alternatives were available, highlighted how investing in authentic relationships pays dividends. Leaders should focus on enriching connections that nurture community spirit rather than maintaining just transactional relationships. Lesson Three: Embrace and Share Struggles Transparency about struggles not only builds authenticity but creates relatability. Venardos openly acknowledges his mistakes and how they shaped his identity and brand. By embracing vulnerability, leaders can foster trust within their teams and audiences. This relatable aspect unlocks an opportunity for shared learning and growth, essential for both personal and organizational development. The Future of Leadership: Inspired by the Circus As we look ahead, it’s evident that the principles exemplified by Venardos resonate well beyond the circus. They emphasize the need for leaders to be present, aware, and responsive to the three rings of influence: their teams, their customers, and their investors. Like a ringmaster, today's leaders must navigate these arenas with finesse, ensuring balance and attention to each group's needs. In a rapidly evolving business landscape, these personal connections will be crucial for sustainable success. Ultimately, Venardos’s story serves as a beacon for those in leadership positions. By focusing on community impact, emotional connections, and openly sharing struggles, we can cultivate a business environment that not only adapts to change but flourishes through it.

Why Jay Schwedelson Says Attribution in Marketing is Garbage

Attribution in Email Marketing: Why It May Be Overrated

Rethinking the Inbox as a Social Space

Holdout Groups: A Better Way to Measure Impact

The Future of Marketing Is About Value, Not Attribution

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Core Modal Title